Victorian Psycho review: Monroe's killer nanny is a mixed bag
- Nov 16, 2026
Maika Monroe spent years being the girl running from the killer. In Victorian Psycho, she finally gets to be the killer, and she grabs the axe with both hands.
The verdict: Monroe is a blast, and the film around her is a handsome, wicked lark that never quite delivers the blood or the laughs its title promises. Critics are split: it has 73% on Rotten Tomatoes from 89 reviews, but a middling Metascore of 54.
Monroe plays Winifred Notty, a governess who arrives at a gothic manor called Ensor House in 1858. She teaches the children their manners while hiding her psychopathic streak, and as the staff start disappearing, the family begin to wonder about her.
Jason Isaacs and Ruth Wilson play Mr. and Mrs. Pounds, the owners of the house, and Thomasin McKenzie is the nurse, Miss Lamb.
Zachary Wigon, who made the 2023 thriller Sanctuary, directs from a script by Virginia Feito, adapting her own 2025 novel. It premiered in the Un Certain Regard section at Cannes in May. Bleecker Street then moved it from a September release to Friday, Nov. 13, and is selling it as coming "from the producer of Longlegs".
| Site | Score |
|---|---|
| Rotten Tomatoes (critics) | 73% (89 reviews) |
| Rotten Tomatoes (audience) | 60% (50+ ratings) |
| Metacritic | 54 (22 reviews) |
| Rating | R (strong bloody violence, brief sexual material) |
| Runtime | 1h 42m |
| Where to watch | In US cinemas from Nov. 13 |
Checked Nov. 16, 2026.
Monroe goes full villain
The reason to see it is Monroe. After It Follows, Watcher and Longlegs, where she was the one in danger, she gets to play the danger, and she's clearly loving it.
Screen Daily's Nikki Baughan called her performance "deliciously gung-ho", and Inverse's Katie Rife put her menace neatly: "Her voice is soft, and her eyes are hard."
Even the harshest review gives her credit. The AV Club's Jacob Oller praised her for "seizing the rare opportunity for villainy", even while he panned almost everything else.
Isaacs and Wilson are fun as the awful lord and lady of the house, played with what Baughan called "a straight-faced irony". Rife singled out a mummy-viewing party that "effectively conveys the grotesque callousness of the Victorian upper classes".
It looks the part, too. The story is set on the Yorkshire Moors, and Jeremy Reed's production design and Allyson Byrne's costumes are full of period detail with dark accents, according to Screen Daily. Nico Aguilar shoots the manor with off-kilter framing, and Screen Daily said the palette is "mostly restrained and often silhouetted by candlelight". Baughan summed up the whole film as "an audacious mash-up of repressed 19th-century literary classics and bloody serial killer films".
The Film Stage liked the jokes as much as the scares: "More than a well-crafted thriller, Victorian Psycho proves a rousing comedy."
The Daily Beast went further, calling it "a superb period-piece horror show" that delivers what its title promises, and The New York Times line Bleecker Street put on the poster calls it "a deliciously deranged psychological horror thriller".
Where's the blood?
The problem is that a film called Victorian Psycho should be wilder than this.
For a horror-comedy, it's surprisingly polite. "The film is all talk when it comes to gore," Rife wrote, and Oller (D+) said the murders are telegraphed and the film "lacks rhythm or intensity".
The voiceover is the other sticking point. Winifred narrates most of the film, and Oller complained she "simply cannot shut up". The dreamy golden look that some critics loved, he found closer to a period drama than a horror movie.
Even its fans admit the satire isn't subtle. Baughan said the class jabs "may be on the nose" and the feminist points are "nothing groundbreaking".
Audiences seem to agree with the middle of the road: the Rotten Tomatoes audience score sits at 60%.
So who is it for? If you liked the wink of Longlegs and want to see its star let loose, Monroe alone makes this worth a ticket, and the R-rated, 1h 42m runtime keeps it moving.
If you came for a bloodbath, wait for streaming. Victorian Psycho has a killer lead and a lovely look, and spends too long admiring both before it swings the axe.