Paper Tiger review: a gripping mob drama with a career-best cast
- Nov 16, 2026
James Gray has made a career out of family, crime and New York. Paper Tiger brings all three back, and the critics are calling it one of his best.
The verdict: a tense, bleak, beautifully acted crime drama with three stars at the top of their game. It takes its time, and the middle stretch leans into melodrama, but the final act will have you gripping the armrest.
It's 1986 in Queens. Miles Teller plays Irwin Pearl, a mild engineer whose older brother Gary (Adam Driver), a former cop, turns up with a lucrative business deal. The money comes from the newly emerging Russian mafia, and when one of the brothers sees something he wasn't meant to, the mob comes for the whole family.
Scarlett Johansson plays Irwin's wife, who has to hold that family together.
| Site | Score |
|---|---|
| Rotten Tomatoes (critics) | 85% (117 reviews) |
| Metacritic | 81 (32 critics) |
| Rating | R |
| Runtime | 1h 55m |
| Where to watch | In select US cinemas now, nationwide from Nov. 20 |
Checked Nov. 17, 2026.
Three stars at their best
The cast is the headline. IndieWire's David Ehrlich gave it an A and called Driver's turn "a career-best performance that stretches across flash, menace, and pure sincerity".
The Los Angeles Times' Amy Nicholson put it more simply: "Driver wears the role of his '80s hotshot as effortlessly as Drakkar Noir."
Teller is the quiet centre, the brother in over his head, and Spectrum Culture said Gray "extracts extremely high-level performances out of Miles Teller and Adam Driver".
But Johansson may be the biggest surprise. Time's Stephanie Zacharek called her "superb", and The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney went further: "Johansson has never been better."
Old school, in the best way
This is a slow burn. Time called it "old school in the best way", and Elle's Tomris Laffly named it "a new American classic". The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw gave it four stars, and RogerEbert.com's Brian Tallerico gave it four out of four.
Tallerico also put his finger on what stays with you: the film is "consistently entertaining, with a low hum of tension from nearly its opening scenes", but "it has a bleakness that isn't entirely apparent until it's over."
Not everyone was sold. Variety's Owen Gleiberman called it a "mouthy, close-knit Jewish domestic psychodrama" that becomes a "mixture of the grandiose and the implausible".
Early audience reviews land in the same place. One called it "chilling" with "terrific" performances, while another felt some of the characters' decisions "defy even the film's shaky internal logic". Several praised the tense final sequence in the tall grass.
A family story
Paper Tiger is personal. In 2024, Gray said his next film would be "about my family, but not from my perspective, maybe from my parents' perspective."
It would pick up his parents' story after Armageddon Time. His father, he said in 2022, "actually did achieve some financial success but wound up getting it all confiscated by the government when he got into legal trouble."
The cast changed along the way. Anne Hathaway and Jeremy Strong were first attached, then dropped out because of other commitments, and Johansson and Teller stepped in. Gray shot it on 35mm in New Jersey on a $15 million budget.
Is it worth it?
Paper Tiger premiered in competition at Cannes in May, where it got a 10-minute standing ovation, and opened the New York Film Festival.
Its opening weekend gave Gray the best per-screen average of his career: $215,000 from just six screens in New York and Los Angeles, or $35,835 a screen, according to TheWrap.
If you like your crime dramas grown-up, tense and heartbreaking, this is a return to the gritty New York crime dramas Gray made his name with. If you want a fast-moving mob movie, be patient: the payoff is worth it.
Paper Tiger is rated R and runs 1 hour 55 minutes. It's in select US cinemas now and opens nationwide on Friday, Nov. 20.