The sixth episode of The Midnight Club opens with Kevin resuming his earlier narrative, except with more gore and graphic details. Using a hammer on his own sibling, Dusty kills once more. Dusty didn't want to, but because of the shrill voices, he's been hearing that shout out "Harmony," Dusty is forced to.

The detective investigating the case keeps prying into this by asking about Einstein, the chatroom Kevin has been stalking in. When prodded to reveal his own username, he makes the dubious claim that he only has one. Although Dusty is naturally reticent, she wants to know more.

That evening, the voices reappeared, identifying "Sheila" as their desired next victim. But of course, there will be another installment!

Ilonka perks up and makes the decision to share a story of her own before they depart for the evening. It's called "Witch," and it's a tale of fate, magic, and love. However, the main focus is on a girl who wants to save someone.

The main character in this story is Imani. Imani and her mother are both healers who have the ability to "scry," or cast images from their psyche onto the water. What then are these pictures? They are, in fact, hints at the future. The mother of Imani cautions her daughter to use it carefully.

Imani's mother, on the other hand, possesses an even more bizarre talent: the ability to heal and save lives. It drains her life power in the process. She collapses on the floor as she works to revive a woman who has been shot fatally, just as Imani arrives.

Imani begins scrying at night as a result of her grief, despite her mother's cautions. She witnesses a boy being shot dead there.