Successfully unsubscribedUnsubscribed

Please allow up to 10 days for processing. Please allow up to 10 days.

The real Home Alone house in Winnetka, Illinois, Dec. 1, 2021.
Michael Gordon / Shutterstock.com

'He was just awful': director names the only actor he ever fired

Movies

By Emma Nguyen

- Nov 17, 2026

Home Alone director Chris Columbus has opened up about the one actor he ever had to fire, and it was one of the Wet Bandits.

Columbus, 68, says the man first cast as Marv, the burglar opposite Joe Pesci, was "just awful" in a screen test.

He didn't name him. But actor Daniel Roebuck admitted years ago that he was the original Marv, and that he was sent home after about four days.

Columbus told the story on Tuesday on Wildmen, the podcast hosted by his son Brendan Columbus and Dylan Sprouse, The Daily Beast reported.

Chris Columbus at The Thursday Murder Club UK premiere, London, Aug. 21, 2025.
Chris Columbus at The Thursday Murder Club UK premiere, London, Aug. 21, 2025. Fred Duval / Shutterstock.com

'They were horrible'

Columbus said he always wanted Pesci and Daniel Stern as the Wet Bandits, but the studio "wouldn't pay" for both.

"So I said, 'OK, let's go with Pesci,'" he recalled. Then they "went with this other guy," and the pair had no chemistry.

"We did a screen test, and they were horrible," Columbus said. "I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was… just awful. And that's the only person I ever had to fire."

He admitted he didn't know what to say when he broke the news, so he softened it with a promise: "We'll work together at some point."

They never did.

Joe Pesci, who played Harry, at a celebrity golf event in Burbank, Oct. 4, 2021.
Joe Pesci, who played Harry, at a celebrity golf event in Burbank, Oct. 4, 2021. Eugene Powers / Shutterstock.com

The wettest handshake

Roebuck told his side on the What a Character! podcast in 2023, and it was no happier. He believes he was never going to make it to the screen.

"I was never gonna be Marv," he said. "Now that's the one thing they never say. I was never ever ever going to film as Marv."

He said he could tell from the start. "I got the wettest handshake of my life with [writer and producer] John Hughes. It was the most disappointing handshake I ever received because I was a fan of the guy. And he clearly didn't want me to be there. It was all so obvious."

Daniel Roebuck, the original Marv, at the Chiller Theatre Halloween Expo, Oct. 30, 2026. · View this photo on Getty Images

He also remembered Columbus's promise.

"Chris Columbus said I will give you a great part of my next movie," Roebuck said. "Now, I notice he's done 20 since then and he's never called. But what really was disappointing was, you know, no one ever just told me the truth."

The mistake that paid twice

Stern got the part in the end, and played Marv beside Pesci in the 1990 hit and in Home Alone 2: Lost in New York in 1992.

The twist, according to Columbus, is that the studio still had to pay Roebuck. The mistake cost it more than if it had paid for both Stern and Pesci from the start.

Roebuck did fine. He went on to more than 277 projects, including Matlock, Nash Bridges, Glee, The Fugitive and Agent Cody Banks, The Daily Beast noted.

Page Six reached out to representatives for Columbus and Roebuck for comment. Meanwhile, People reported in July that a new Home Alone is in early development at Disney.